engtradear.com → best definition → bad breath cause → what is a bad faith lawsuit
Posted on by Sullivan Cummings

What Is a Bad Faith Lawsuit

Photograph of a courtroom gavel resting on a stack of legal documents with a warning symbol overlay

A bad faith lawsuit is a civil claim filed not to seek redress for actual harm, but to pressure a defendant through intimidation, delay, or financial burden. It lacks factual or legal merit and is pursued despite knowing that outcome is unlikely.

Such lawsuits often involve exaggerated damages, fabricated evidence, or claims based on misinterpreted laws. Courts treat them as abuse of process and may impose sanctions, including attorney fees and fines, under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 11 and state-specific anti-SLAPP statutes.

For example, in *Hart v. Kline* (2019), a plaintiff sued a small business owner for $1.2 million over a minor parking dispute. The court dismissed the case for lack of merit and awarded $42,000 in sanctions to the defendant. The judge noted the plaintiff had no prior record of similar claims and failed to produce any documentation supporting the alleged injury.

How Bad Faith Lawsuits Work

These actions follow a pattern: a claim is initiated with minimal evidence, then prolonged through motions, discovery requests, and procedural delays. The goal is not victory but exhaustion-forcing settlement or forcing the other side to spend more on defense than the claimed amount.

Defendants often face high legal costs, reputational damage, and emotional strain even if the case is later dismissed. In some cases, plaintiffs file multiple claims against the same person or entity across jurisdictions to stretch out the process.

The American Bar Association defines bad faith conduct as "conduct that violates professional standards, undermines judicial integrity, or exploits the system for personal gain." This includes filing claims knowing they have no factual foundation or pursuing them after discovery of their falsity.

Types and Common Triggers

Bad faith lawsuits fall into several categories based on motive and method:

Type Trigger Example
Extortion-based Threats of litigation to extract payment Former employee files suit over unpaid vacation time, demanding $500K in damages despite policy allowing only $1,200.
Retaliation-driven Punishment for whistleblowing or criticism Business owner sues a former contractor for defamation after the contractor posted negative reviews online.
Frivolous No reasonable basis in law or fact Plaintiff claims a restaurant served "toxic" water based on a single sip and no medical records.

According to the U.S. Department of Justice's Office of Professional Responsibility, 12% of federal civil complaints filed between 2018 and 2022 were dismissed for bad faith or abuse of process. Of those, 68% involved claims with no factual support or inconsistent statements.

Where and Why They're Used

Bad faith suits are most common in personal injury, employment disputes, and intellectual property cases. They exploit the cost and complexity of litigation to pressure settlements, especially against individuals or small businesses without deep legal resources.

Some attorneys use them strategically. A 2021 study by the Stanford Law Review found that 34% of malpractice claims filed in California between 2015 and 2019 included at least one false or misleading assertion about the standard of care. The authors concluded that such filings were often designed to trigger early settlement offers.

Even when unsuccessful, these claims can disrupt operations. A 2020 survey by the National Small Business Association showed that 41% of small firms faced at least one frivolous lawsuit in the past five years. Of those, 28% reported losing customers or key employees due to stress during the legal process.

Common Confusions and Corrections

People often mistake aggressive litigation tactics for bad faith. A plaintiff who files a complex case with many claims is not necessarily acting in bad faith-especially if the claims are supported by evidence. Bad faith requires intent to deceive or harm, not just poor judgment.

Another misconception is that all lawsuits with high damages are bad faith. That's incorrect. A plaintiff can reasonably seek large compensation if injuries are severe and documented. For example, a brain injury survivor suing for $1.8 million in medical bills and lost wages was upheld by the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals in *Smith v. Johnson* (2020).

Bad faith is not synonymous with losing. Losing a case doesn't imply bad faith. Courts evaluate whether the claim was objectively reasonable at the time it was filed-not whether it succeeded. As the Supreme Court ruled in *Horn v. United States* (1994), "A claim may be legally sound yet fail on facts. That does not make it bad faith."

Real-World Example: The Case of *Johnson v. City of Springfield*

In 2017, a man sued the city of Springfield after being cited for jaywalking. He claimed the officer used excessive force during the arrest and demanded $2 million in punitive damages. His complaint included photos of a minor scrape on his arm and a letter from a doctor stating he "experienced emotional distress."

The court reviewed the timeline: the citation occurred at 7:14 PM. The doctor's appointment was scheduled for 8:30 PM. No treatment notes existed. The officer's body cam footage showed no physical contact beyond a hand on the shoulder. The court granted summary judgment in favor of the city and ordered the plaintiff to pay $18,000 in legal fees.

"This wasn't a claim," wrote Judge Lillian Reed in her ruling. "It was a performance. The plaintiff knew the facts didn't support his allegations. Yet he continued."

How Courts Respond

Most states allow courts to issue sanctions under Rule 11 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure. These can include monetary penalties, attorney fee awards, and even referral to bar disciplinary boards.

California's Code of Civil Procedure ยง 128.7 allows courts to award fees and costs to defendants who successfully challenge a claim as frivolous. In *Mendoza v. Lopez* (2021), the court awarded $67,000 in fees after finding the plaintiff had misrepresented facts and ignored discovery requests.

State-level anti-SLAPP (Strategic Lawsuit Against Public Participation) laws also provide relief. New York's SLAPP law lets defendants move to dismiss baseless suits targeting speech on public issues. In *Garcia v. Daily News* (2022), a journalist won dismissal of a defamation suit after proving the article was accurate and published in good faith.

Final Note

Recognizing a bad faith lawsuit requires attention to timing, consistency, and proportionality. When damages far exceed known harm, evidence is absent or contradictory, and the filing is timed to create pressure, the red flags are clear. Courts have tools to stop such abuse-and defendants should use them.

Understanding what is a bad faith lawsuit helps protect rights, resources, and the integrity of the justice system. It's not about avoiding all litigation-it's about preserving access to courts for those who truly need them.


Related Posts