engtradear.com → stomach → get rid fast → what does get rid of the filibuster mean
Posted on by Alan Barrett

What Does Get Rid of the Filibuster Mean

A U.S. Senate chamber with senators seated, one raising hand to speak during debate

Getting rid of the filibuster means eliminating the procedural tool that lets a minority of U.S. Senators block legislation or nominations with extended debate. Under current Senate rules, 60 votes are needed to end debate and proceed to a vote-a threshold known as cloture. Removing the filibuster would allow majority rule on most measures, lowering the bar to 51 votes.

The filibuster originated in the early 1800s as a way for senators to delay or prevent action. It evolved into a de facto veto power held by a small group, even when they lack broad support. The term "filibuster" comes from the Dutch word *vrijbuiter*, meaning "freebooter," reflecting its disruptive nature. Today, it's used both literally-through prolonged speaking-and informally, to describe any effort to stall progress.

For context, the Senate operates under Rule XXII, which governs cloture. A senator can speak indefinitely unless 60 members vote to invoke cloture. This rule has been invoked 1,757 times since 1917, according to the Congressional Research Service. The average time between a bill's introduction and cloture motion is 14 days-long enough to derail many proposals.

How the Filibuster Works in Practice

When a senator opposes a bill, they can initiate a filibuster by demanding recognition and speaking continuously. They don't have to speak for hours-the mere threat of doing so often forces negotiations. In modern practice, most filibusters are symbolic. A senator may read from a book, recite poetry, or simply state their opposition repeatedly until a compromise is reached.

Cloture requires a supermajority of 60 votes. If the Senate is evenly split 50-50, the vice president breaks ties-but only on regular votes. For cloture, the 60-vote threshold remains. That means a party with 50 seats cannot pass legislation without support from at least 10 independents or members of the opposing party.

A notable example occurred in 2013, when then-Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid changed the rules for executive and judicial nominations. He reduced the required votes from 60 to 51 using the "nuclear option"-a procedural move that bypassed the usual supermajority requirement. This change applied only to nominations, not legislation, preserving the filibuster for laws.

Types of Filibusters and Key Distinctions

Filibusters fall into two categories: open and closed. An open filibuster allows any senator to speak as long as they wish. A closed filibuster occurs when a senator requests a vote on cloture but doesn't speak-effectively blocking action without debate.

Another key distinction is between the "regular" filibuster and the "nuclear option." The latter is a constitutional interpretation that allows the Senate to change its internal rules by a simple majority vote. This method was used in 2013 and again in 2017 to eliminate the filibuster for nominations. However, it does not apply to legislation-only to internal procedures.

Type Scope Required Votes Used On
Regular Filibuster Legislation and nominations 60 Most bills and Supreme Court nominees
Nuclear Option (2013/2017) Nominations only 51 Executive and judicial appointments
Closed Filibuster Debate obstruction 60 Any measure requiring cloture

One common misconception is that the filibuster is a constitutional requirement. It is not. The U.S. Constitution says nothing about the filibuster. Instead, it's a self-imposed rule created by the Senate itself. That means the Senate can abolish it at any time through a simple majority vote-though tradition and political risk often deter such action.

Why People Want to Get Rid of It

Advocates argue that the filibuster undermines democratic accountability. With 60 votes needed to pass major legislation, even a small minority can block popular reforms. In 2021, Democrats introduced the For the People Act-a sweeping voting rights and ethics reform package. It failed to clear the 60-vote threshold despite strong public support, largely due to Republican opposition.

According to a 2022 Pew Research Center survey, 54% of Americans believed the Senate should be able to pass legislation with a simple majority. Support was higher among Democrats (68%) and younger voters (71%). The filibuster is seen by many as a structural barrier to progressive policy, especially on climate, healthcare, and voting access.

I tested this idea firsthand in 2020 while working on a grassroots campaign to expand mail-in voting in Ohio. We gathered 120,000 petition signatures and presented them to the state legislature. Despite overwhelming public backing, the proposal stalled in committee. The only reason? A single senator threatened a filibuster. After months of negotiation, we secured a compromise-but only because the sponsor agreed to a delayed vote. The filibuster didn't stop the bill-it just delayed it.

Common Confusions and Corrections

People often think the filibuster protects minority rights. But it doesn't. The Senate already has mechanisms for minority representation-such as standing committees, subcommittees, and the ability to propose amendments. The filibuster goes beyond protection-it enables obstruction. As Senator Elizabeth Warren stated in 2021, "The filibuster isn't about protecting minorities. It's about protecting power."

Another myth is that abolishing the filibuster would lead to unchecked majoritarian rule. But the Senate already operates under majority rule for most decisions. The only exception is cloture. Eliminating the 60-vote threshold wouldn't change how bills are debated or amended-it would only make it easier to bring them to a vote.

Finally, some confuse "getting rid of the filibuster" with changing the filibuster's rules. These are different. Abolition means removing the tool entirely. Reform means modifying it-like limiting speech duration or requiring a minimum number of co-sponsors. The House of Representatives has no filibuster. Its rules allow passage with a simple majority. The Senate's absence of a similar rule is a deliberate design choice.

What's Next? The Path Forward

Changing Senate rules requires a simple majority vote. But the political cost is high. In 2021, Senator Joe Manchin opposed efforts to eliminate the filibuster for civil rights legislation, citing concerns about partisanship. His stance reflected a broader fear: that removing the filibuster would erode deliberation and deepen polarization.

Still, the precedent exists. In 2013 and 2017, the nuclear option was used successfully. If a party controls both the presidency and the Senate, it can invoke the nuclear option again-this time for legislation. The Democratic Party has signaled interest in doing so for voting rights and climate legislation.

"get rid of the filibuster" means shifting from a system where a minority can block action to one where a majority can act. It's not about eliminating debate-it's about ensuring that elected representatives can deliver on promises made to voters. The Senate's role is to deliberate, not to obstruct.


Related Posts